Image for blue and red swoop graphic

What To Do When Bathtub Faucet Won’t Turn Off

By Aztil –

Image for What To Do When Bathtub Faucet Won’t Turn Off

A bathroom is a sacred place. You go there first thing in the morning, the last thing in the night, and many times in between. Since you frequently use it you want, all items must be clean, tidy, and in proper working order. 

It is the place where you find solace in the form of a nice long soak or a fast rejuvenation of the tired soul through a quick shower. Sometimes you may even go there to hide from your little brats and get some quiet time. 

At such times, even a leaking and dripping faucet is a big irritation. Even worse is you go in for a bath, and when the time comes to turn off the faucet, it just doesn’t do what it is supposed to. Not only is your precious water running away, but it may also damage the floor and walls. This is a tricky situation and a valid cause for concern. The purpose of this article is to reduce your anxiety and tell you exactly how to proceed when your bathtub faucet won’t turn off.

What To Do When Bathtub Faucet Won’t Turn Off

The situation calls for an expert, which in this case is the plumber. However, he is not waiting at your doorstep, so you need to get a handle on things yourself. The apparent solution is repairing the faucet yourself. It’s an excellent time to learn the basics of faucet repairs now so that in future you can take care of things on your own. 

Fixing The Faucet

Sometimes the problem is really simple and needs just a small fix. To begin with, your first course of action should be to tighten the handle screw. 

Step 1 – Since the flow of water has not stopped, you need to shut off the water supply completely. The valve that controls the water supply to your home will be somewhere close to where your water heater is fitted.

Step 2 – Take a pic of the faucet and its handles. It will come handy while buying new parts or explaining to the plumber.

Step 3 – Using a flat-blade screwdriver, pry beneath the cover plate to reveal the handle screw. Sometimes tightening this screw will solve the problem. Use a Phillips screwdriver to tighten it.

Step 4 – Restart the water supply to your home and turn the faucet on and off to see if you have managed to fix the problem.

If tightening of the handle screw does not solve the issue, it’s time to aim big. You have to try and repair the end of the stem.

Step 1 – Again, you need to begin by turning off the water supply so that you do not flood the bathroom.

Step 2 – From the faucet, you need to remove the handle. For this, rotate the handle until it comes off the stem. You may need to use a wrench to complete this action. At times, a gentle pull can also do the trick.

Step 3 – Examine the faucet stem end for any kind of damage. Ideally, the stem tip has rims or ridges which attach to the ridges that are inside the handle of the faucet. When these get worn or spoiled, the faucet handle is unable to tighten around the stem. Due to this reason the faucet unable to turn off. You need to replace the part whose rims have smoothened out over a period of time.

Step 4 – Carefully have a peek inside the faucet handle to detect any obvious damage. A handle which is cracked would need complete replacement. Again, this because it will not grip the faucet stem correctly. When the grooves or ridges inside the handle get worn out, the handle can’t attach with the stem properly. As a result, it cannot regulate the faucet.

Step 5 – Clean the stem end to remove any deposits or debris. You can use an old toothbrush to do so. Once done, with the help of a rag wipe the stem dry.

Step 6 – Wrap a couple of layers (one or two) of thread-seal tape all around the valve stem tip. Now, push or firmly press in the handle over the stem through the layers of thread-seal tape. Another way is to rotate the handle over the stem until it locks in position.

Step 7 – Finally, turn on the water supply once again to check whether the fix works or not. If it works, remember, the thread-seal tape is a temporary fix. It will increase the life of the faucet stem and handle from anywhere between a few months to a year or two. Ultimately, you just have to replace them.

When Your Fix Doesn’t Work

It is not necessary that your repair will hold for long or that it even fixes the problem. If the problem does not fix at all, shut down your water supply and call the plumber immediately. If your fix works only for a short duration, you are probably not doing it correctly. Even then you need to call the plumber to come and address the issue once and for all.

Tips To Keep In Mind

1) Cover the drain with a cloth so that no small pieces or spare parts fall into it. These can clog the drain and also make for unnecessary purchases to replace them.
2)Put a protective sheet in your tub so that you don’t accidentally leave scratches or stains of any kind.
3) When working with pipes, wear protective gloves . This way, you will not hurt yourself on any sharp edges.
4) Wearing safety goggles is also advisable so that you don’t get any stray particle inside your eye.

What We Advise

Some works cannot be done by all. There are professionals who are trained to handle them. Having said that, it is not possible to get hold of these people at a moments notice. A plumbers job is one such. In the absence of a plumber, you need to be knowledgable enough to handle a minor crisis. You need to know the basics of handling any situation so that your suffering is limited. Hopefully, this article will help you in the future.

Request Service

What Our Clients Think Of Us


Wow, thank goodness for Aztil !!!!
The AC went down yesterday evening 7pm, and Niko G & Elder Z (with Aztil) was here by 11 am this morning and had everything up and running in less than an hour. He was very professional and accommodating. He took the time to explain what was the issues were and the repairs that were done.
Thanks Juan for coming out and saving us from the relentless Florida, summertime heat 😊👍😊

up and run
Response from the owner:Carol Haber, thank you for your review! We are glad to hear that Juan was able to get your AC up and running quickly. We appreciate your kind words and thank you for choosing Aztil.
Michael was teriffic. Great technician and very pleasant
Response from the owner:Hi Mel, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to hear that Dana did an excellent job and that you were pleased with the outcome. Thank you for being a valued customer.
Dana is the technician. He is very professional and thorough, I will make every effort to utilize his service at my home whenever possible.
Aztil has always been a very reliable and professional company, and Nico was a terrific and professional technician who was able to diagnose our problem. We were just surprised that our out-of-pocket was almost $2000 even with a maintenance contract and a warranty on the compressor.
George (Jorge) is excellent and very professional. Very please with quality of his work and taking time to explain and get me up and running w/new WiFi system. Definitely would recommend him!!
AZTIL sent a Tech named Michael King and he was awesome and respectful. He exerted due diligence to perform the maintenance right the first time. He was detail oriented , courteous and knowledgeable. He made the right decision to ensure our safety. He briefed after his work.

Thank you Michael for great job!!!

My rating is 5.0 which you deserve!

Dr Benjamin US Army MSG Retired PSL
Tech Nico very helpful did a great job will request him again. Thanks.
Ramon was punctual, friendly, knowledgeable and quick. He explained everything he was doing even showing me the old part he replaced. Great Job as always!
Niko was our technician and did a great job. He explained everything very clearly and was professional the entire time he was here. I highly recommend Aztil and Niko for your AC service and maintenance needs.
Very Prompt, technician Alex was professional and explained everything he was doing. We have been with Aztil for over 15years. They have been recently taken over by a larger firm but still keeping the name Aztil . So far so good .
Dan ,
10/13-25
He was a great technician!
Nico was great! He went above and beyond for us!
Excellent customer service. My technician, Niko, was very knowledgeable and walked me through all of my AC issues.
Antonio was awesome, got their membership deal, worth it for AC repair and maintenance. He fixed the problem quick and was efficient. Great experience, thank you
niko is so great and professional!
Nicholas Garza was pronto didn’t even have to wait!!!! Took care of business and cooling off🥰😎😊😉
Niko was fabulous as usual. He took a good amount of time to talk with us about our AC
There are some problems to be resolved and Niko explained the options
We appreciate his time and efficiency
Niko did a great job , rate him a 10
Nico did a great job with my AC units.
Niko was very knowledgeable and helpful!
Paul Gross was my technician. He was extremely knowledgeable and friendly. Called before he showed up and really helped my family and I out. More guys like Paul!
Nikko did great tune up service on our Unit and has great customer service skills.
my apartment is cold. Lazaro is a greagt guy.
Niko. Excellent work
Nino did a ac tuneup, spent the time to check everything and even changed the thermostat batteries for me.
Response from the owner:Hi Marci, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to hear that Niko did an excellent job and that you were pleased with the outcome. Thank you for being a valued customer.
Nico Garza came to do AC maintenance. He was professional, courteous & great at his job. Highly recommend & will request him in the future. Its time for him to have a 5.0 rating.
Response from the owner:Hi Robyn, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to hear that Michael did an excellent job and that you were pleased with the outcome. Thank you for being a valued customer.
Contract maintenance call was done by a very professional service technician Niko. Would recommend his service to anyone. No cost
Great service Juan was wonderful keeping me informed and solves the problem so pleasant
To work with thank you Juan
Niko was very professional, diligent & thorough with cleaning all of the air vents throughout my home. He was also on time and made sure to clean up any mess that was left behind.
Response from the owner:Hello. We're so glad to hear that Mr. Ricardo was professional, diligent, and thorough with cleaning the air vents in your home. We take great pride in ensuring that our customers have a positive experience with us, and we're glad to hear that Mr. Ricardo was on time and left your home clean. Thank you for your review!
We have been using Aztil for more than 10 years, and are quite satisfied with their prompt service. In the last service call, Ramon Serpa did a great job.
Niko- he was very polite, respectful and got the job done right away. He even put back the closet folding door which we would have not been able to put back. Clean job.
Great Guy! Explains everything very well! Good employee's are hard to find and he is one of them!
Skyler did an excellent job with the duct cleaning. Thank you so much for your service.
Just wanted to express my appreciation for the fantastic service provided. Niko (Service Tech), did a fantastic job! He was professional and respectful. He's a great asset to your team.
I would recommend this company Dana was great he helped fix the ac. He came and it was a one day fix and we are cool as cucumbers again! Thank you! He worked are and got the job done.
Niko serviced my a/c this afternoon and did an outstanding job. I believe he went above and beyond my expectations. Ask for Niko, you won't be disappointed.
Nico. Very professional!
Niko was very nice and professional and patient.
Niko very efficient would like him to come here for all future calls
Niko. Excellent job. Aztil is fortunate to ha him in their employ. Thank you! Under contract
Niko. Excellent service. Request he return for next 6 month maintenance visit
Niko was very knowledgeable and helpful.
Technician Dana was very professional. He had the new A/C replacement motor ready in a few minutes and left everything clean and working.

Join The Club

Request more information by filling out the form below to learn about our Elite Cool Membership Program.

Highlights of the Elite Cool Membership Program include:

  • Members will receive priority service: Get top priority when scheduling service calls.
  • No overtime charges: We’re here for you anytime, day or night, 365 days a year, without any overtime charges.
  • A 15% member discount: Receive a 15% preferred discount on repairs not covered by the manufacturer.
  • Two maintenance calls per year: Benefit from two maintenance calls per year, spaced about six months apart.
  • AND MORE!

Need more information? Click below to call now!

Call Now

Our Partners


  • Carrier logo
  • Honywell logo
  • Mitsubishi Elctric logo
  • York logo
  • American Standard logo
  • Amana logo
  • Trane logo
  • Rheem logo
  • Ruud logo
  • Daikin logo